Wild Roots Diary »

Masthead header

DIY Sweet Catsup

After picking a large amount of tomatoes, I realized I had no idea what to do with them. I started going through my vintage herb books and stumbled on a recipe titled “Sweet Catsup”. I have never attempted a recipe that does not have photos before and this recipe had minimal instructions, which is not good for me as I am not the best cook in the world. I decided to go for it and was so excited when the recipe actually turned out great! The recipe is from “Rodale’s Basic Natural Food Cookbook” and I added a few extra ingredients of my own.





Sweet Catsup

2 cups tomato puree

2 cups tomato juice

1 cup cider vinegar

1/2 cup of honey

1 tsp dry mustard

1 stick of cinnamon

1/2 tsp whole allspice or tsp ground allspice

2 stalks celery with leaves

2 medium-size onions

I added:

pinch of fennel

pinch of coriander

In a heavy saucepan, combine tomato puree, tomato juice, vinegar, honey and mustard. Place over medium hear and bring to a boil.

Place cinnamon and allspice in a clean, thing, white cloth. Tie top tightly. Add to catsup mixture. Then add celery and onions. Bring to a boil, reduce heat, and cook, uncovered, until catsup is thick, about 3 hours. Stir occasionally during cooking.

Remove spices with a slotted spoon, remove celery and onions. Pour catsup into a heated glass container with tight -fitting lid, cool at room temp, and then store in refrigerator.

Yields around 1 pint.



I prepared the tomatoes by cutting of the tops and putting a slice in the bottom so the tomatoes would cook evenly.






I blanched the tomatoes which made it easier to pull the skin off. If you want to skip this step you can buy tomato puree at the grocery store. I also made my own tomato juice but this step could also be skipped and purchased at the store.IMG_0015

I I added the rest of the ingredients to the pot.IMG_0017IMG_0019AF



After the mixture cooked down and the sauce was at the desired thickness, I strained the sauce and used a funnel to pour it into bottles.